Skip to main content

Table 1 The characteristics of included studies in the meta-analysis

From: Prolonged screen watching behavior is associated with high blood pressure among children and adolescents: a systematic review and dose–response meta-analysis

References

Journal/Year

First author/Country

Setting/num

Design

Study group

Age (y)

HTN definition

BP measurement

ST definition

ST measurement

Main findings

[42]

Plos One/2020

Solomon-Moore E/UK

School/1283 + 797

Cross-sectional

Prospective (OR reported)

Children

9–11

 ≤ 95th for age, sex and height

Omron 907

Video games/PC/TV/movies

Accelerometer

No correlation between sedentary time and HTN was reported. There was a significant positive relationship between sedentary time and high SBP

[40]

Scand J Public Health

Pederson J/Denmark

Community/964 + 963

Cross-sectional

Children

3–5

 ≤ 95th for age, sex and height

Electronic oscillometric

Video games/PC/tablet/TV/movies

Parent reported-daytime ST

No association between sedentary time and HTN was reported. A positive association between pre-bedtime ST and HTN was reported [1.57 (95% CI 1.02; 2.42) and 1.82 (95% CI 1.18; 2.89)], respectively, for 2–5 days/week and more than 6 times/week

[24]

BMC Pediatrics/2019

Zou Y/China

School/3737

Cross-sectional

Adolescents

12–15

 ≤ 95th for age, sex and height

Mercury Sphygmomanometer

Smartphone addiction

Smartphone Addiction Scale short version

Smartphone addiction was positively associated with HTN (OR = 2.205, 95% CI: 1.273–3.820)

[6]

Cien Saude Colet/2018

de Oliveira/Brazil

School/2524 + 3773

Cross-sectional

Adolescents

14–17

 ≤ 95th for age, sex and height

Omron HEM 742

Video games/PC/tablet/TV/movies

Self-reported

TV viewing was associated with high BP among boys. No significant association between ST and HTN among girls was reported

[4]

J Am Soc Hypert/2018

Karatazi K/Greece

School/1243 + 1230

Cross-sectional

Children + adolescents

9–13

 ≤ 95th for age, sex and height

Mercury Sphygmomanometer

Video games/PC/tablet/TV/movies

Self-reported

Boys in isolated systolic HTN had higher ST compared with others (P = 0.002); also, higher ST was associated with significantly higher odds of ISH (1.13 (1.04–1.23). No significant association between ST and HTN was observed

[17]

BMC Pediatrics/2018

Barstad LH/Norway

Clinic/268

Cross-sectional

Adolescents

12–18

 ≤ 95th for age, sex and height

Digital oscillimetric device, Dinamap ProCare

Time in front of the TV- or PC

Self-reported

Those in high ST group had higher SBP

[43]

Biomed Res Int/2017

WyszyNsk J/Poland

Community/568

Cross-sectional

Children + adolescents

7–18

 ≤ 95th for age, sex and height

Mercury Sphygmomanometer

Video games/PC/TV/movies

Self-reported

More than 2 h/d ST in school days was associated with higher odds of HTN [2.74 (1.25–6.04)]

[44]

Nutrients/2017

Gui ZH/China

Community/79,725

Cross-sectional

Children + adolescents

6- 17

 ≤ 95th for age, sex and height

Mercury Sphygmomanometer

Video games/PC/TV/movies

Self-reported

Those with more than 2h/d ST had higher odds of pre-HTN and HTN (5% and 6% higher risk, respectively)

[45]

Int J Obes/2017

Cureau FV/Brazil

School/36,956

Cross-sectional

Children + adolescents

12–17

 ≤ 95th for age, sex and height

Omron HEM 705

Video games/PC/TV

Self-reported

Those with more than 6 h/d ST had higher odds of HTN [1.21 (1.08–1.35); P = 0.003]

[46]

Iran J Public Health/2015

Safiri S/Iran

School/5625

Cross-sectional

Children + adolescents

10–18

 ≤ 95th for age, sex and height

Mercury Sphygmomanometer

TV/VCDs/PC

Self-reported

High SBP and DBP in those with high ST (P < 0.001)

[20]

Blood Pressure/2015

Christofaro DGD/Brazil

School/1231

Cross-sectional

Children + adolescents

10–18

 ≤ 95th for age, sex and height

Mercury Sphygmomanometer

TV/VCDs/PC

Self-reported

Higher odds of HTN (1.68) and higher ST in hypertensive compared with normotensive children and adolescents

[19]

Int J Obes/2014

NE Berentzen/Netherland

School/2651

Cross-sectional

Children + adolescents

11–12

 ≤ 95th for age, sex and height

Omron M6

TV/PC

Self-reported

No significant difference in SBP or DBP in highest versus lowest ST quartiles

[47]

Am J Prevent Med/2013

Stamatakis E/Portugal

School/2515

Cross-sectional

Children + adolescents

2–12

 ≤ 95th for age, sex and height

Omron M7

TV/VCDs/PC

Parent -reported

High SBP and DBP in those with high than 2 h/d screen behaviors

[18]

Psychosom Med/2013

Berendes A/Germany

Community/825

Cross-sectional

Children + adolescents

11–17

 ≤ 95th for age, sex and height

Sphygmomanometer

TV/VCDs/PC

Self-reported

Higher odds of HTN among those with more than 2 h/d TV, VCD and more than 0.5 h/d PC exposure (P < 0.001)

[48]

J Korean Med Sci/2012

Byun W/Korea

Community/577

Cross-sectional

Children + adolescents

12 -18

 ≤ 95th for age, sex and height

Sphygmomanometer

TV/VCDs/PC

Self-reported

No significant association between odds of HTN and screen behaviors

[41]

BMC Public Health/2011

Carson V/USA

Community/2527

Cross-sectional

Children + adolescents

6–19

Highest versus lowest BP quartiles

Sphygmomanometer

TV/PC

Accelerometer

No significant association between odds of HTN and screen behaviors

[49]

J Sports Sci/2010

Ullrich-French SC [49]/USA

School/153

Cross-sectional

Adolescents

11–15

 ≤ 95th for age, sex and height

Sphygmomanometer

TV/VCDs/PC

Self-reported

Higher SBP in those with more than 2 h/d screen behaviors (P < 0.001)

[50]

Arch Ped Adol Med/2010

Hardy LL/Australia

School/496

Cross-sectional

Adolescents

14–17

 ≤ 95th for age, sex and height

Mercury Sphygmomanometer

TV/DVDs/videos/PC for recreation

Self-reported

Odds of higher DBP in boys with more than 2 h/d screen behaviors [3.30 (1.35–8.12; P < 0.001)]

[51]

J Hum Hyper/2009

Lazarou C/Cyprus

School/622

Cross-sectional

Adolescents

10–13

 ≤ 95th for age, sex and height

Mercury Sphygmomanometer

TV

Self-reported

No significant association between odds of HTN and TV watching

[26]

Am J Prev Med/2007

Pardee PE/USA

Clinic/546

Cross-sectional

Children + adolescents

4–17

 ≤ 95th for age, sex and height

Self-reported

TV

Parent and self-reported

Higher odds of HTN among those with 2–4 h/d and more than 4 h/d compared with those with less than 2 h/d TV watching [OR:2.54 (1.51–4.29 and OR:3.29 (1.95–5.59, respectively]

  1. HTN hypertension, TV television, ST screen time, BP blood pressure, SBP systolic blood pressure, DBP diastolic blood pressure, PC personal computer, DVD digital video discs, VCDs video compact disc digital
  2. All of the studies evaluated both genders. Except of the study by Pardee [26] that was performed among obese children and adolescents, other studies recruited apparently healthy children and adolescents